• This question is in relation to divorce

My wife sent me a lawyer notice, which we didnot accept. After that we sent the notice, which they accepted & she replied with false allegations of dowry & domestic violence. Now we are planning to file a divorce case with court & reply to her notice along with the court case filing details.
Our concern is that can she file a police criminal case against us even after we filed for divorce in court? And can police come & arrest us at home for which we will have to apply for bail or once the divorce case is filed with court, there cannot be any police case until court comes to a conclusion?
The thing is that we come from a respected family & we did not have any police charges against us in the past & my parents are afraid that police may come to our house & arrest uncessarily even though we did not ask for dowry & in reality there was no domestic violence, but her false allegations may put us in trouble. Please assist can police come to our house & arrest even after filing for divorce? If yes, then please advice how can this be avoided? We are happy to fight in court because I know we didnot do any such thing & hence, she will not have evidence to prove. Thanks for your help in advance.
Asked 8 years ago in Family Law
Religion: Hindu

2 answers received in 30 minutes.

Lawyers are available now to answer your questions.

11 Answers

11. ys, she can file case u/s498A IPC or case under PWDV Act at any point of time.For filing such cases she need wait for you to file divorce suit forst.

2. However in 498A cases the automatic arrest has stopped.The police will first send you a notice u/s41a after which you can apply for anticipatory bail and once you get that all the concern of 498A case vanishes.

3.So there is no need to get scared of arrest though police would come to your house but for the purpose of service of notice u/s41A CRPC.

4. So there is no need to fear necessarily.

Devajyoti Barman
Advocate, Kolkata
23582 Answers
534 Consultations

1)wifecan file case for dowry harassment even after you file for divorce

2)you would not be arrested merely because FIR is lodged

3) you can obtain anticipatory bail for yourself and family members

4) policewould merely issue younotice to record your statement

5) do not bow down to blackmail tactics

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
98944 Answers
8049 Consultations

They will call you and other accused to police station to record your statement

2) don't file for divorce first

3) let wife file for divorce and you can contest the divorce case

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
98944 Answers
8049 Consultations

1. If you did not accept her notice then how can you reply to it?

2. You are free to file for divorce, but this will not preclude her from filing 498A or any other criminal case. In the event FIR gets registered apply for and obtain anticipatory bail.

3. Police is bound to issue you a notice before arresting in 498A.

4. Police records the statement in police station, not home.

Ashish Davessar
Advocate, Jaipur
30830 Answers
977 Consultations

Our concern is that can she file a police criminal case against us even after we filed for divorce in court? And can police come & arrest us at home for which we will have to apply for bail or once the divorce case is filed with court, there cannot be any police case until court comes to a conclusion?

It is her decision to lodge a criminal complaint or not, it cannot be predicted.

The police will not come to yor house to arrest you but they may summon you to the police station,

You can obtain AB at that time and then visit the police station.

It is not necessary that they will have to wait for the court order however generally the police will not make any such attempt during the pendency of bail application decision.

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
89145 Answers
2442 Consultations

But, will police record the statement at home only while delivering the notice or they will take the family members to the police station?

The police would summon you people for inquiry and investigation to the police station and they may not record your statements at your home. .

Secondly, is it advisable in my scenario to file the case first??

If you have any grievance agaisnt her you may proceed with filing any such case as you decide about it

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
89145 Answers
2442 Consultations

1. police record statement at PS only .They would not take you to PS also.

2.You can wait little longer to decide on filing the suit.

Devajyoti Barman
Advocate, Kolkata
23582 Answers
534 Consultations

1. if she files domestic violence case you cannot be arrested until you breached notice of the court.

2. if she files case for cruelty under section 498 A then again you cannot be arrested according to direction given by the supreme court in arnesh kumar case.

3. if you have decided to file divorce case you may do so, if she files any case in counter blast of divorce case then court may presumed it as cross case hence it will loose credibility.

Shivendra Pratap Singh
Advocate, Lucknow
5127 Answers
78 Consultations

1. She can of course file a complaint against you and/or your family members u/s 498A of IPC even after you file th divorce suit.

2. As a precautionary measure, you should now lodge a police complaint against her alleging that she has threatened you that she will file a false 498A police complaint if you file a divorce case against her.

3.As per supreme court direction, police will not make any arrest immediately based on your wife's complaint. So, do not worry.

4. Police will make investigation first based on her complaint for which you shall be called at the police station for conducting investigation.

5. If police registers a FIR based on your wife's complaint, then you and all tye accused shall have to avail anticipatory bail from the Court first and then contest the case fittingly.

6. Engage a local lawyer having expertise in this field.

Krishna Kishore Ganguly
Advocate, Kolkata
27606 Answers
726 Consultations

1. Ordinarily police calls all the accused to the police station and record their statements.

2. You should co-operate with police fully and ensure that no FIR is registered by te police after conducting the said investigation.

3. If police registers FIR, hen all the accused shall have to obtain AB as suggested in my earlier post.

Krishna Kishore Ganguly
Advocate, Kolkata
27606 Answers
726 Consultations

Dear Concerned

Lets look at this step by step

FIRSTLY - PLEASE NOTE there is no value of a Legal Notice Sent By a Lawyer in a Matrimonial Case. Hence DO NOT REPLY TO THE legal notice sent by your wife through a lawyer - YOU will end up writing your defense.

SECONDLY - There is no Automatic Arrest in false matrimonial cases i.e the Dowry Demand and Cruelty case filed by wife. If your wife complaints - you will get a call from the concerned police station - you must visit and mention your side of story -DO NOT give anything in written to the police.

THIRDLY - FILE A DIVORCE before your wife does anything - ie a false DV complaint or false police complaint. The Hon'ble Apex Court has given some serious views toward the RETALIATORY complaints filed by wife after Husband file any divorce or separation case. Hence go ahead and file DIVORCE without delay - mention all your fact in the same and dont reply to your wifes legal notice.

POLICE delivers Summons and not notice - notice is sent by a lawyer - police delivers summons from court , infact in matrimonial case summons will come via post and not police.

YES go ahead and file a case.

Best of luck

Atulay Nehra
Advocate, Noida
1314 Answers
58 Consultations

Ask a Lawyer

Get legal answers from lawyers in 1 hour. It's quick, easy, and anonymous!
  Ask a lawyer