False FIR and arrest under section 302 & 201 IPC
My brother has been named as an accused and arrested (currently in Police Custody) in a murder case and section 302 and 201 IPC have been registered in the FIR.
The incident happened in the year 2012 wherein the victim (a good friend of my brother) and my brother had went out late night for a night out/dinner. While returning back home they were stopped at a police nakabandi and were asked for identification which was promptly provided by both of them. The friend was riding the bike and he dropped my brother home and was returning back to his place at around 2.45am, he met with an accident on the way home (approx. 1-2 kms away from our place). The body was found next day and panchnama was conducted. The post-mortem report states case of "unnatural death", death was due to suffocation as the victim's bike skidded off the road and he fell into a nullah (murky water was found in his lungs). The victim's mother named my brother as he was the last person to be seen with the victim (police nakabandi being an evidence), whereas my brother was at home when this accident occured.
The case is currently in District court and we will be filing it at Sessions court after the remand period gets over. In this case scenario, I would like to know from legal criminal experts on what should be our next course of action, how strong is the case and how can he prove himself innocent in this matter. Although my brother has been in remand from more than a week, no formal inquiry/interrogation has been made.
Please guide me.
Asked 9 years ago in Criminal Law
Thanks for replying to my question.
The exact cause of death as mentioned in the PM is as below:
“Asphyxia as a result of combined effect of suffocation and choking consequent to complete impaction of respiratory passages and oral cavity with brown clay murky matter in a person having body surface injuries. “Investigation officer to investigate the manner of death”.
We already have an lawyer for this case who is working towards getting my brother out on bail.
Here are some facts of the case:
1) After the accident my brother was called for inquiry numerous times but he was able to remain present at the police station only once as he was working in Mumbai and was not able to get leave. The IO kept asking him to come to meet him at the PS but he was afraid that they might put a false case and arrest him. Eventually on our lawyer’s advice he applied for an anticipatory bail which was granted to him as the police had not registered any case against him and they needed him only for inquiry.
2) In the meanwhile my brother got a job abroad and applied for an PCC which was issued to him and he traveled abroad in 2013. They however kept calling him for inquiry and were told that he was out of country so they registered a FIR against him.
3) He was informed by our lawyer that an FIR has been registered against him and he has to be present to come out of the case clean. Accordingly he was returning back to appear at the police station when he was arrested at the airport by Immigration officials and since then he has been handed over to the local police and is under remand.
4) The police remand gets over today and he will be sent to judicial custody, we will be applying for bail at sessions court.
I would like to know the following:
1) Although my brother is at fault as he did not co-operate with the IO for the inquiry into this case, has this made the matters worse for him?
2) As he applied for an anticipatory bail, does he become the prime suspect?
3) Does his traveling abroad meanwhile during this case makes him an absconding accused?
4) During the last argument at district court for extension of police remand the public prosecutor argued and stressed on the “last seen” theory as the base of the FIR and said that they need investigate further, if they had any further incriminating evidence should not that have been the base of the argument?
From the time of his arrest till the expiry of his remand period he has not been interrogated,just kept in the lock up. We also got an offer to “settle” this issue at a hefty price as my brother was now an NRI.
Your expert advise is highly appreciated.
Asked 9 years ago