Clarify the overlap context in writing by documenting a clear explanation addressed to your prospective employer, stating: the exact timeline of your employment and sabbatical leave; that the two companies operated in entirely different domains with no conflict of interest; that once you realized the overlap, you immediately resigned to rectify the situation; and that since then, you have had a clean career record with no further dual employment or anomalies.
You mentioned you are willing to put this in writing—this is good and should be done in a formal email or affidavit.
Request reconsideration with supporting documents. Along with the statement, provide any supporting documents such as resignation letter from the second company, employment letters confirming dates, sabbatical sanction letter or approval, and PF statements showing employment timelines if available. Use these to strengthen your clarification and request reconsideration.
Negotiate with the employer or HR. Sometimes policy is rigid, but if you can offer a detailed explanation, consent to write no-dual-employment declaration, and assure your best commitment, some employers may reconsider.
Try alternate channels. If the employer refuses reconsideration, ask if they can reconsider after you join probation or provide a second chance based on your integrity record. Attempt contacting higher HR or compliance managers with your explanation. If it’s a critical opportunity, consider seeking help through professional references or internal referrals who can vouch for your character.
Regarding PF Office: as you rightly noted, PF officials generally won't intervene in dual employment disputes during BGV as it’s an employment contractual matter, not a PF violation.
Future prevention and transparency will help avoid such issues: always ensure no overlap in employment contracts, disclose any sabbatical or notice periods clearly during recruitment, and keep transparent documentation of any such leaves or employment breaks.
If rejected, don’t lose hope. BGV rejection on technical grounds unfortunately happens. But many companies consider the overall candidate’s profile and integrity. Keep applying elsewhere and explaining the issue proactively to prevent misunderstanding.
Legal remedy is limited since BGV and hiring decisions are at employer discretion, unless there is discrimination or violation of contract. Focus on proper documentation and communication.
In summary, prepare a clear written explanation with supporting documents, formally request reconsideration, offer a no-dual-employment declaration, and engage HR patiently. If refused, seek alternate offers with upfront clarifications. Maintain transparent and consistent employment records to avoid future issues.
If you want, I can help you draft your explanation letter or advise on communication strategies with the employer. Please feel free to contact me for a professional consultation tailored to your case.