Q.1, May he waits for one year completion from the date of marriage to initiate process for filing divorce case against you on the grounds of mental cruelty.
Q. Based on your experience in legal field, does this seem like a closed case (that he indeed wants us to file for divorce) or is he only acting out of fear? I am asking this since once I go legal, there could be no way I could restore this relationship due to bad blood.
Both of you have started taking defence steps to defend each other in the known or advised way towards the future litigation that both consider to file against each other, therefore wait and watch the development without interacting with him anymore.
Q. His repeated evasiveness and lack of any positivity has led me to firmly believe that since their expectations were not met, maybe he does not want to continue in this relationship. He never contacts or speaks to me or my family. But since I never had this in mind, I obviously was not in business of collecting proofs or recording etc unlike him. I feel extremely cheated that he so easily duped me and now I can't even prove that they all harassed me for money and this is the real reason behind his abandoning him. Instead he has gone out to the whole world alleging I abused and tortured him. Feel helpless.
Actually your email giving the entire account of your helping him monetarily provoked him to react that way trying to defend himself before being offended or slapped with dowry harassment offences. You may send a restitution notice if he remains unresponsive.
Q. Should dowry harassment cases always be accompanied with concrete proofs? In that case what about innocent girls who do not have this in mind while starting a new pious relationship- They would never have proofs so to say.
No concrete proofs necessary for a complaint against the dowry harassment, mere complaint in writing will be sufficient for an investigation/inquiry by police who will submit their report accordingly.
Q. Is the women's commission correct in this? Should I seek their help for mediation once and if my terms are not agreed either for living together or separation, only then approach court for filing any criminal case? Need suggestions based on your experience and good faith.
State women welfare commission will be of much help to the destitute and hapless women. In such cases like yours they may extend help to certain extend but they cannot provide you the desired help, they cannot enforce any right, you may have to approach court of police seeking proper relief.
Q. Should I report this to the police and file a missing person complaint as well since I do not know where my husband is living for past 6 months? When should I do this - first file police complaint and then send legal notice for separation to his ancestral house address? He does respond occasionally to my father on email or phone call.
First you send a legal notice to his last known address or in the probable address, if he is not responding or it is returned then you may approach police with man missing complaint.
Q. Does that mean for a working woman, anyone can simply marry her and spoil her life forever by abandoning her at will? That court will not grant her damages just because she is working. What about the damage done to her life and emotions, the uncertain personal future that comes with it.
You can very well lodge complaint against him for dowry harassment, cheating and breach of trust. You can file DV case for violence and compensation for abandoning you after marrying you for the sake of extra dowry, seeking residential rights, seeking protection, you can file a civil case seeking compensation for the damages for the mental losses he caused to you in the name of marriage and abandoning you without any reason. There are lot of legal avenues open before you, but they are to be identified and utilised properly through an experienced and skilled advocate.
Q. Please guide on the best strategy - step wise to ensure that if he is seriously not willing to work out this relationship and has done so for money/girlfriend etc, I am able to punish him sufficient. Such people will only spoil one more life if this it is so easy for men. (Marry for money - if not fulfilled - provoke and record and accuse of mental torture and abandon wife - remarry new girl - seems to be my story)
You may think on the above lines and plan your strategy accordingly.