Definition of cruelty U/S 498A not fitting reasons mentioned in my FIR
Under "IPC 498a was made to protect a woman from injury to life or limb, or mental harassment to the extent to drive her to suicide. All problems in marital life do not attract 498a, to the extent made clear in this SC judgment too".The Definition of cruelty U/S 498A : Clause A) Cruelty, such a nature, which drive a wife to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health. (Need Medical Report for this to prove). Clause B) Harassment for unlawful demand (Dowry). So, any other cruelty which does not falls under said Clause A & B(e.g. slapping, abusing or having extra marital affairs etc.) cannot be chargeable U/S 498A. So in my case my Wife couple of months back logged FIR with IPC( 498a , 504, 506)& mentioned i hava done cruelty upon her for past Two years, Out of which for 1 year( till date )I am not staying with her. And before Two years. Earlier we stayed happily for 6 years. In her FIR Wife has clearly mention that upon inquiring me about extra marital affair by naming a girl whom she doubt,I created fights & abused her & threaten her (BUT NOT LIKE WILL KILL YOU or BEAT YOU)in anger and me due to my affair use to harass Wife Physically ,mentally & emotionally. There is no evidence of any audio recording of me abusing her or threatening her nor Physical abuse evidence AS I am not past 1 year I am not staying with WIFE. Also there is no evidence causing physical or mental harassment leading the my wife to cause grievous hurt or to commit suicide is not there, she stays at her Mom home. How strong is my case to go for Quashing rather than wait & watch for Trial to come in court & prove myself innocent ? I dont want to waste time & due to FIR i dont even go out of Mumbai for anything i have to take permission & also cant apply for new JOB since i feel I should not mention anything in application Form else they will reject me if they see any records in court, considering i work with Private firm. My charge-sheet has not been submitted by local police yet as they will take their own sweet time. Also i noticed before FIR of (498a),I heard CAW Cell is informed but i dont think in my case i have been asked to meet any CAW Cell. Local THANA PRO called me twice 1st time for NC & second time to record my statement & third time i had initiated settlement & Divorce discussion with WIFE which was before FIR when i went to THANA. And suddenly 1 day i got a call that there is 498a FIR against me.I have not been informed by Police that they will be going to put 498a & other sections etc. Immediately after FIR I have applied for Divorce & my 1st hearing is due in few days as my Lawyer told me if I would have applied for Divorce. earlier then local Police cant register FIR as it becomes CIVIL matter. Now i have 2 cases running for which I have hired CIVIL & Criminal lawyer but none give me clear directions. (1)Shall i ask go for quashing of FIR under sec 482 of CrPC (2) Shall i wait & watch for Trial to come in court ? AB is taken.
Asked 7 years ago in Criminal Law
Religion: Hindu
Since wife filed FIR with section IPC (498a, 504, 506) mentioned me having Extra marital affair which lead to mental & physical cruelty & abuse. I took Anticipate Tory bail from Mumbai Sessions court.
And Immediately I filed for Divorce & now my hearing is due
My lawyer told me a must appear in Civil Court & my wife & me will be sent to Councilor for Counseling first time. So, my question is what strategy I should adopt. Is my Wife turns up on that day then?
-- In in front of Councilor Judge in Civil court I can say I want to patch-up & stay with her & revive for better future?
-- I am 1000% sure my Wife will not be going to come back to me, so she will say No in front of Councilor.
-- So, if she says No my lawyer can justify that since she is saying NO to stay with Husband. Immediate Mutual Divorce is applicable without any further justification & because she Is saying NO, I will not be asked for any Maintenance or alimony.
--How can I use her NO as proof to Fight my FIR & Ask for Divorce (is the concealing session recorded as proof?)
-- And while fighting for FIR I can tell Judge that I have tried patching up with Wife in CIVIL court, but she is refused.
-- Can this turn in my favor while Fighting FIR for IPC (498a, 504, 506) ?
-- If Wife says yes to my offer of Staying back with me. Does in this case my Divorce petition gets dissolved that day itself ?
-- And there are also chances if she wants to delay, she will say yes to my offer & will not come back to me which is diff scenario.
-- But since my Divorce petition is dissolved, I can go for RCR in this scenario?
As I am already not staying with her since past 1.2 years.
Other Scenario would be If she does not turn up then what strategy should I adopt?
Can I still attend Councilor for Counseling & give my Offer & get the statement recorded & use same strategy?
Frankly I am fed-up of police & all legal matter & either wants to settle down in peace or want to get out of all this matter clean
Asked 7 years ago