• Defamation on Facebook and threats to enter the property with local people and media personnel

I had rented out my property to an individual for a period of 3 years.
The rent deed was determined/expired in December 2021.
The tenant was officially evicted from the premises by Municipality in March 2022. After that property remained under police superdari for more than a year.
The former tenant instituted civil proceedings before the Court of the 2nd Additional Munsif, Srinagar, and criminal proceedings before the Court of the Special Mobile Magistrate, Srinagar/Railway Magistrate. Both proceedings were dismissed. His allegations, including allegations of theft and cheating, were dismissed by the Court of the Special Mobile Magistrate.
The civil proceedings were dismissed due to default as he did not appear. 
I have rented out my property to someone else. 
He is uploading defamatory videos on Facebook accusing me of theft, cheating, claiming he invested 50 lakhs on the property. 
Threatening to enter the property with local persons and media personnel. 
What is my legal position? Can he again file criminal complaint or do anything that can cause harm?
His criminal case was dismissed in May 2024.
His civil case was dismissed in June 2025.
How do i protect myself?
What options do I have ?
Has he exhausted all his legal options ?
Asked 12 hours ago in Criminal Law
Religion: Other

Ask a question and receive multiple answers in one hour.

Lawyers are available now to answer your questions.

4 Answers

Your legal position is relatively favorable, but you need to take action immediately. His criminal complaint has been dismissed, and the civil lawsuit was dismissed for non-appearance (not on the merits)—you can argue that his re-filing constitutes abuse of process. However, his defamatory videos on Facebook and threats to bring people onto the property constitute separate new offenses for which you can report to police or file a complaint, and apply for an injunction requiring the platform to remove the content. He has not "exhausted all legal avenues," but his options are very limited.

Will he file another criminal complaint? What are the restrictions?

If his criminal complaint was dismissed on the merits (rather than for procedural reasons), filing another complaint on the same facts faces significant obstacles. According to Indian case law, if the dismissal was based on lack of merit, a second complaint can only be filed in "exceptional circumstances". If the dismissal was merely for non-appearance or procedural reasons, he may attempt to file again, but the court will scrutinize whether it constitutes harassment or abuse of process. In any event, he cannot simply "start over"—the previous dismissal is strong evidence for your defense.

Can you take action against the defamatory Facebook videos?

Yes. Defamation on social media in India can constitute an offense under Sections 499/500 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), and you can also pursue civil defamation claims. You should immediately screenshot and preserve all videos, posts, and comments as evidence. You can report to the cybercrime department and request that Facebook remove the content—Indian courts have precedent supporting orders requiring platforms to take down defamatory content. At the same time, you can file a civil suit seeking damages and an injunction prohibiting him from continuing to publish.

What should you do about the threats to enter the property?

His threat to "bring local people and media personnel to enter the property" may constitute criminal intimidation under Section 351 of the BNS. You should file a written police complaint detailing the specific content, timing, and manner of the threats. If police refuse to register an FIR, you can complain to the Superintendent of Police, or directly file a private complaint before the Magistrate under Section 175(3) or Section 210 of the BNSS. Additionally, ensure the property's locks and security measures are strengthened and install cameras to document any attempted intrusion.

Has he exhausted all legal avenues?

No, but his remaining options are very limited. He could theoretically appeal the civil dismissal (if within the limitation period), but given that he failed to appear, the chances of success are extremely low. He could try to file a new criminal complaint, but as noted above, he faces significant obstacles. What you need to focus on is his ongoing illegal acts—defamation and threats—rather than his expired litigation options. Every new illegal act by him is an opportunity for you to take legal action.

Lalit Saxena
Advocate, Sonbhadra
575 Answers

Your legal position is strong. Because the lease expired in December 2021, the Municipality lawfully evicted him in March 2022, and both his civil and criminal cases were dismissed, he has no legal right, title, or possessory claim over the property. His current actions posting defamatory videos and threatening to enter the premises with a crowd and media constitute criminal offences under Indian law.

If the Special Mobile Magistrate dismissed his complaint on its merits after inquiry, he cannot simply file a fresh complaint on the exact same facts. His only remedy was to file a Criminal Revision Petition before the Sessions Court or High Court typically within 90 days of the dismissal order. Since over two years have passed since May 2024, any revision petition would now be  time-barred unless he proves extraordinary reasons for the delay.As the civil suit was dismissed for non-appearance rather than on merits, he can apply for Restoration of the Suit before the same Munsif Court, or file a fresh suit if the limitation period has not expired. Since it was dismissed in June 2025, he would have to file an application for condonation of delay explaining why he was absent for over a year which courts rarely grant lightly when a party is actively making social media videos instead of appearing in court.

He may try to file a freesh criminal complaint. People sometimes try to harass property owners by twisting facts or fabricating a "new" incident. However since you have official Municipal eviction records, police superdari records, and two prior court dismissal orders, any police officer or Magistrate presented with these documents will immediately recognize it as a vexatious civil dispute disguised as a criminal case.

You may submit a written complaint to the local Station House Officer (SHO) in Srinagar having jurisdiction over the property.  Request them to register a complaint for criminal intimidation and initiate preventive proceedings (under Sections 126 / 168 BNSS) to bind him down from disturbing peace or interfering with your current tenant's peaceful possession. Inform your current tenant to call 112 immediately if anyone gathers outside.

You may even plan to send a legal notice to him objecting his unwanted activities as well as instructing him to delete all defamatory Facebook videos within 48 hours and demand an unconditional public apology on the same platform. You may also warn him that any attempt to enter the property with locals or media will result in immediate criminal prosecution for trespass, unlawful assembly, and extortion, alongside a civil suit for damages.

If he ignores the legal notice, you may file a  Suit for Permanent and Mandatory Injunction (along with an urgent application for an ex-parte interim injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 & 2 CPC) restraining him, his associates, and media personnel from entering the property or interfering with your current tenant, and directing Meta to take down the URLs.

You can also file a private criminal complaint for defamation before the Magistrate under section 222 BNSSand claim monetary damages in the civil suit. 

 

 

 

 

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
91308 Answers
2528 Consultations

On same cause of action he cant

only on fresh cause of action he can

Prashant Nayak
Advocate, Mumbai
35422 Answers
257 Consultations

issue legal notice to ex tenant  to withdraw false and defamatory allegations made against you if he refuses to do so 


File complaint of criminal defamation against the ex tenant 

 

you can also file civil suit for damages against him 

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
101101 Answers
8261 Consultations

Ask a Lawyer

Get legal answers from lawyers in 1 hour. It's quick, easy, and anonymous!
  Ask a lawyer