Your situation involves important issues of succession, civil procedure, jurisdiction, and service of summons abroad, especially because you are a US resident and OCI holder. Here is the correct legal position and how you should respond strategically to protect yourself and your share in the property.
1. Whether you should ignore the summons during your India visit
It is strongly advisable not to ignore the summons, even if you have not been personally served yet.
• If your siblings have been served, the court proceedings have already begun.
• If you travel to India and the plaintiff learns of your presence, they may attempt substituted service against you.
• Ignoring the case may result in the court proceeding ex parte against you, which can seriously harm your rights in the property.
Even if the summons was not personally handed to you yet, it is best to participate through a lawyer, file your appearance, and protect your interests.
2. Does the summons become invalid because you have not been directly served in the US?
No. The Indian court can still treat you as properly served through other legally permitted methods. Under the Civil Procedure Code, the court can order:
• Service through your India address (if available)
• Service through your relatives
• Service by email
• Service by WhatsApp
• Service by speed post
• Service by newspaper publication (substituted service under Order V Rule 20)
So even if the US service procedure is not completed, the court can still deem you served through alternative methods.
3. How summons are legally served to a person living abroad (US citizen / OCI holder)
Technically, when a respondent resides outside India, courts may use:
• Order V Rule 25 CPC – service through the Indian Consulate in the country of residence
• Order V Rule 26 CPC – service through courts in the foreign country (if that country permits)
• Order V Rule 20 CPC – substituted service (publication)
The process may involve:
• Sending the summons through the Ministry of Law & Justice
• Forwarding to the Ministry of External Affairs
• Indian Embassy/Consulate in the USA delivering the summons
However, this formal route is slow and rarely followed to completion unless insisted by the parties. In most practical cases, courts rely on substituted service or electronic service.
4. Can you claim that the summons is invalid because US service procedure was not followed?
No. You cannot depend on that argument. Indian courts are empowered to adopt alternative service if the respondent resides abroad.
If the court passes an order permitting substituted service, then:
• You are legally treated as served
• You become bound to file your written statement
• Failure to appear may result in ex parte proceedings
Therefore, relying on “I was not formally served in the US” is risky and may harm your defence.
5. Why you should file an appearance through a lawyer immediately
• The summons indicates the case is already filed.
• If you do not appear, the plaintiff may seek an ex parte decree, which may affect your property rights.
• Once you enter appearance, the court must give you reasonable time to file your reply.
• Your lawyer can request the court to give you additional time since you live abroad.
• You will be protected even if you are not physically present in India.
6. Whether there is any harm in travelling to India now
There is no legal restriction on your travel. You can freely visit India.
However, if the plaintiff or process server discovers your presence, they may attempt personal service.
But that does not harm you legally—it only accelerates the process. Your best safeguard is:
• Engage an advocate
• File a vakalatnama
• Appear through counsel without waiting for physical service
7. What you should do immediately
• Appoint a civil lawyer in the district where the case is filed
• Your lawyer should inspect the case file and obtain the plaint copy
• Verify what exactly the cousin is claiming and under which law
• File your appearance before the next date
• Seek extra time to file your written statement citing your residence in the US
• Ensure nothing proceeds ex parte against you
8. Important to note: your cousin cannot claim any share unless legally entitled
A cousin normally has no right in your father’s self-acquired property unless:
• He proves a valid will in his favour
• He shows a legally enforceable claim
• There existed a joint family property situation
• He has independent rights (very rare)
Most often, such claims fail. But you must contest them; otherwise, silence may be interpreted against you.