Nominee is only trustee for legal heirs
2) mother can during her lifetime transfer flat in favour of third party without your consent
Is NOC from nominee mandatory for sale of cooperative society flat in Kolkata ? I’m the nominee and my mother is the member in our cooperative society. Is it possible to transfer share to someone else without my permission?
Nominee is only trustee for legal heirs
2) mother can during her lifetime transfer flat in favour of third party without your consent
1. Nominee has no right in the flat and society shares during the lifetime of society member
2. Even after society member passes away, the nominee holds the flat and shares of deceased member, only as a trustee, and does not get any ownership rights whatsoever
3. If society member is alive then she can sell the flat to whomsover she deems fit
4. No permission of nominee is needed
5. Upon the sale, the nominee automatically lapses and the new member can appoint his own nominee
Firslty, there has been a well defined through precedents for the nominee to have the same right as of the real owner.
Secondly, when a name has been there as nominee that means the person is entitle to all rights with respect to the immovable property.
Thirdly, without your NOC the flat can’t be transferred to any one, and if it is done somehow then it will be a fraud as well as forgery.
Nominee have no rights till the title holder is alive. She may dispose the property if it is not of ancestral nature.
Nominee has no legal right in life of the owner he is just trustee for legal heirs so yes mother can sell the flat without your permission.
This is my response to you:
1. Since the nominee has been made in the flat, therefore his/her permission is required;
2. It is better if the NOC is given by the nominee;
3. Though in some societies it is not necessary, since nominee is not the owner, and does not have name on the property records;
4. For precautions sake NOC can be given.
The answers that I’ve received here are mixed. So what would you recommend so that without my permission the transfer cannot happen? Is there some legal way I can make sure that my noc is mandatory? Thanks
Dear Client,
Nominee has no say in the property neither his/her NOC is required to sell the property. A person who receives the benefit in case of death of the person is a nominee.
If property belongs to mother not inherited from father, she can sell it to any.
as earlier stated, nominee has no right over the flat and society shares
the owner member i.e. your mom can do whatever she wishes with her flat
there is no way you can stop her legally from doing so
Sir the flat can be sold by the owner without permission of the Nominee no NOC is required from nominee by the owner of the property. The owner has power to even alter the nominations.
Hii
Greeting s of the day.
Yes but obvious by law the NOC is mandatory from Nominee. To avoid any legal complication in future one should obtained a NOC from legal hiers and Nominee.
Best regards
1. Your mother is the title holder of the flat and is also the share holder of the said Society.
2. She has nominated you or taking possession of her said flat and ubstitute your name in the share certificate issued by the Society after her demise.
3. She has not registered any deed of conveyance to authorise you to claim title of the said flat.
4. Your mother can very well sell her said flat without even informing you since she is the sole owner of her said flat.
1. Your mother is the sole title holder of the said property.
2. Your consent is not required by her for dealing with her said property because of the reason that you have been made her nominee for the said flat.
The very purpose of nominee is to take over possession of the proeprty and distribute the same to the class I legal heirs of the deceased owner, hence the nominee will come into effect only after the demise of the owner therefore nominee cannot assume extra ordinary powers on the property especially when the owner is living.
The nominee has no rights in the property during the lifetime of the owner hence he need not be consulted before transferring the property by sale to any person.
As per law of nomination, the nominee is just a trust to receive the property on behalf of the class I legal heirs of the deceased owner of the property and to distribute the same to the beneficiaries.
The nominee will have no role to play in respect of this property during the lifetime of the owner of the property.
Therefore your NOC or permission is not at all required.
1. IF the Nominee name is endorsed on the Society's Share Certificate, THEN it becomes mandatory for the Society to ask for your affadavit /NOC, before making any further Transfers.
2. Search the Internet with the following key words "Nomination in Housing Society". The article will give proper perspective on the rights of the Nominee
3. IF you are a Legal Heir of the Flat-Holder, THEN a proper legal notice can be served to the Society to desist and refrain from making any further Transfers, without your express written consent, else you would file relevant prosecution in the Court, against the Society Committee members.
Keep Smiling .... Hemant Agarwal