• Withdraw and refiling application in Execution Petition

Application filed by JD under section 47 cpc in Execution Petition raising some objections and after prolonged period it argued by both DH and JD. Then Executing Court fixed next date for order. On the date of order where court was about to pass order suddenly JD not press that application without forwarding any application without assigning any reason orally submitted he is not pressing application. So that application was not pressed and Court filed it. Tbe interesing part at the moment he not pressed the application, immediately he filed replica of said application without permission of court on which Court has asked DH to file reply. The question arises from the act of JD are as below : 1. Withdrawing application under section 47 cpc when order was about to pass on fix date after concluding argument without assigning any reson and filing a replica by appointing a new advocate without seeking liberty /permission of the court falls under which provision of law (Order 23 rule 4 cpc does not apply to execution proceeding as per my advocate). Is a important question as i want to file reply on new replica application with supportive Judgment.. If anyone knows about law provision and any relevant judgment, please come forward
Asked 16 hours ago in Civil Law

First answer received in 10 minutes.

Lawyers are available now to answer your questions.

4 Answers

1) Even though Order 23 does not apply directly to execution proceedings due to Rule 4, courts consistently hold that the underlying principle of Order 23 Rule 1(4)—which bars a party from instituting a fresh proceeding on the same subject matter after abandoning or withdrawing an earlier one without liberty—applies to miscellaneous and execution applications on grounds of public policy

 

 

2)  Unconditionally withdrawing an application after arguments have concluded—simply because the JD sensed an unfavorable order—and immediately re-filing the exact same application through a new counsel is a textbook abuse of the process of the Court. The Executing Court has inherent power under Section 151 CPC to dismiss such a repetitive application in limine (at the threshold

 

3) A JD cannot be permitted to stall execution indefinitely by filing serial applications raising the same objections

 

4


  • Sarguja Transport Service v. State Transport Appellate Tribunal (AIR 1987 SC 88):The Supreme Court held that even where Order 23 CPC does not strictly apply (in that case, writ petitions), the principle underlying Order 23 Rule 1 must be extended in the interest of administration of justice and public policy. If a party withdraws a petition after hearing without seeking permission/liberty to file a fresh one, a second petition on the same subject matter is barred. In para 8 of this judgment, the Supreme Court specifically noted the common tactic where counsel senses the court is not inclined to pass a favorable order and withdraws the petition without liberty—holding that a fresh application on the same cause of action cannot be entertained

 

 

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
101117 Answers
8261 Consultations

The core legal basis for your reply is that the judgment debtor (JD) orally withdrew the Section 47 CPC application without the court's permission and without reserving the right to re-file, which constitutes an unconditional abandonment of that objection; thereafter, filing an application with identical content is essentially an attempt to re-litigate matters that have already been withdrawn, and the court should not accept it. Your lawyer is correct that Order 23 Rule 4 does not directly apply to execution proceedings, but the Supreme Court has made clear in Shiv Prasad A v. Durga Prasad (2026) that a party's withdrawal of an application is effective upon being communicated to the court, and no formal court order is required; subsequent steps do not affect the validity of the withdrawal. More importantly, the Supreme Court in Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Aptech Ltd. (2024) held that unconditional withdrawal without liberty makes a second application on the same cause of action non-maintainable, and this principle has been applied by analogy to non-suit applications to prevent abuse of process. You should argue in your reply that the JD's conduct constitutes a deliberate waiver of the right to object, and the re-filed application is an abuse of process; request the court to dismiss it under Section 151 CPC to protect the integrity of the execution proceedings. Key authorities to cite: Shiv Prasad A (effectiveness of withdrawal) and Arif Azim (unconditional withdrawal bars re-filing). Additionally, note that the JD's re-filing with a new lawyer is a clear attempt to circumvent the consequences of the earlier withdrawal and should be viewed with suspicion.

Lalit Saxena
Advocate, Sonbhadra
586 Answers

Your advocate is technically right that Order 23 Rule 4 CPC explicitly excludes the direct statutory application of Order 23 (Rules 1 to 3) to execution proceedings. Because the earlier Section 47 application was dismissed as "not pressed" rather than decided on merits, strict res judicata (Section 11 CPC) will also not apply.

ou can strongly oppose the maintainability of this second application in your reply.

However you may please note that even though Order 23 Rule 1 does not apply in terms to execution proceedings due to Order 23 Rule 4, Indian courts have consistently held that the principle of public policy underlying Order 23 Rule 1(4) applies to all judicial proceedings to prevent endless litigation, but, once a party voluntarily abandons or does not press a claim without obtaining express liberty from the court to file a fresh one, they waive that right and are precluded from re-agitating the exact same subject matter.

Point out the exact dates—when the first Section 47 application was filed, when arguments concluded, when it was fixed for orders, and the exact date it was orally "not pressed" without assigning any reason or obtaining liberty.

Pray that the application be dismissed at the threshold as not maintainable on grounds of public policy (relying on Sarguja Transport Service) and as a gross abuse of the process of the court under Section 151 CPC..

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
91325 Answers
2529 Consultations

Based on the facts shared, I am of the opinion that you have a substantial ground to oppose the subsequent application filed by the Judgment Debtor under Section 47 CPC.

The first application was contested at length by both parties, arguments were concluded and the matter was fixed for orders. However, on the date fixed for pronouncement, the Judgment Debtor suddenly chose not to press the application without assigning any reason and without seeking liberty to file a fresh application. Immediately thereafter, the Judgment Debtor filed another application containing substantially the same objections, without obtaining the Court's permission.

It is important to note that Order XXIII Rule 4 CPC expressly excludes the application of Order XXIII to execution proceedings. Therefore, the subsequent application cannot be rejected merely on the ground that Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC applies. However, this does not give the Judgment Debtor an unrestricted right to repeatedly file applications raising identical objections.

In my view, the stronger objection lies under Section 151 CPC, read with the principles of finality of proceedings and prevention of abuse of the process of the Court. A party should not be permitted to abandon an application after completion of arguments and when the matter is fixed for orders, only to reintroduce substantially identical objections through a fresh application and thereby delay execution of the decree.

The Supreme Court's judgment in Pradeep Mehra v. Harijivan J. Jethwa (2023 INSC 958) is relevant in this regard, as it emphasizes that execution proceedings should not be delayed by permitting repeated rounds of litigation and reopening of issues at successive stages.

However, the Judgment Debtor may rely upon Joginder Singh v. Dr. Virinderjit Singh Gill (2024 INSC 814), wherein the Supreme Court considered the effect of dismissal for default of objections under Section 47 CPC and observed that such dismissal does not ordinarily operate as res judicata against raising the same objections again. We will therefore need to distinguish that judgment on facts, particularly because, in your case, the earlier application was argued at length and was not pressed only when the matter was fixed for orders.

I would suggest that your reply specifically highlight that the second application is substantially identical to the earlier application, that no fresh cause or circumstance has been disclosed, and that the Judgment Debtor has deliberately adopted this course to delay execution of the decree.

You should seek dismissal of the subsequent application with costs, request the Court to take note of the Judgment Debtor's conduct, and pray that the execution proceedings be continued without granting further unnecessary opportunities.

I would also recommend preparing a comparative statement of both applications, identifying the identical grounds, averments and prayers. This will help demonstrate that the subsequent application is merely a repetition of the earlier one.

One important clarification is required: Was the first Section 47 application formally disposed of by a judicial order recording that it was not pressed, or was it merely recorded in the order sheet that the Judgment Debtor's counsel did not press it? This distinction will materially affect the legal grounds to be taken in your reply.

 

For detailed legal advise you may connect on https://share.google/jCbuYXivLzFBy0dSK

Yuganshu Sharma
Advocate, Delhi
1687 Answers
5 Consultations

Ask a Lawyer

Get legal answers from lawyers in 1 hour. It's quick, easy, and anonymous!
  Ask a lawyer