Based on the facts shared, I am of the opinion that you have a substantial ground to oppose the subsequent application filed by the Judgment Debtor under Section 47 CPC.
The first application was contested at length by both parties, arguments were concluded and the matter was fixed for orders. However, on the date fixed for pronouncement, the Judgment Debtor suddenly chose not to press the application without assigning any reason and without seeking liberty to file a fresh application. Immediately thereafter, the Judgment Debtor filed another application containing substantially the same objections, without obtaining the Court's permission.
It is important to note that Order XXIII Rule 4 CPC expressly excludes the application of Order XXIII to execution proceedings. Therefore, the subsequent application cannot be rejected merely on the ground that Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC applies. However, this does not give the Judgment Debtor an unrestricted right to repeatedly file applications raising identical objections.
In my view, the stronger objection lies under Section 151 CPC, read with the principles of finality of proceedings and prevention of abuse of the process of the Court. A party should not be permitted to abandon an application after completion of arguments and when the matter is fixed for orders, only to reintroduce substantially identical objections through a fresh application and thereby delay execution of the decree.
The Supreme Court's judgment in Pradeep Mehra v. Harijivan J. Jethwa (2023 INSC 958) is relevant in this regard, as it emphasizes that execution proceedings should not be delayed by permitting repeated rounds of litigation and reopening of issues at successive stages.
However, the Judgment Debtor may rely upon Joginder Singh v. Dr. Virinderjit Singh Gill (2024 INSC 814), wherein the Supreme Court considered the effect of dismissal for default of objections under Section 47 CPC and observed that such dismissal does not ordinarily operate as res judicata against raising the same objections again. We will therefore need to distinguish that judgment on facts, particularly because, in your case, the earlier application was argued at length and was not pressed only when the matter was fixed for orders.
I would suggest that your reply specifically highlight that the second application is substantially identical to the earlier application, that no fresh cause or circumstance has been disclosed, and that the Judgment Debtor has deliberately adopted this course to delay execution of the decree.
You should seek dismissal of the subsequent application with costs, request the Court to take note of the Judgment Debtor's conduct, and pray that the execution proceedings be continued without granting further unnecessary opportunities.
I would also recommend preparing a comparative statement of both applications, identifying the identical grounds, averments and prayers. This will help demonstrate that the subsequent application is merely a repetition of the earlier one.
One important clarification is required: Was the first Section 47 application formally disposed of by a judicial order recording that it was not pressed, or was it merely recorded in the order sheet that the Judgment Debtor's counsel did not press it? This distinction will materially affect the legal grounds to be taken in your reply.
For detailed legal advise you may connect on https://share.google/jCbuYXivLzFBy0dSK