• Challenge interim maintenance order

Hi,
I married in Apr 2015 in Lucknow and lived together in Pune as I was working there. My wife left me in Aug 2016 filing a fake MLC report but no FIR. We had no children. She held Masters and had work exp of 7 years with last salary of 18K before wedding.

Despite many reconciliation attempts at her native place lucknow, she never came back and demanded 20L for mutual divorce.. very reluctantly I agreed for that in 2018-19 and we filed it from my hometown in MP. I had already left my job in Feb 2018 and she was aware. However, I changed my mind saying I am ok to live together or for MD without any money and cannot pay as I was not earning and lost my savings in stock Market trading. I had returned all her belongings and jewelry with a receiving from her.

My wife sent me Bangalore lawyer's notice with lot of false allegations in Dec 2020 which I didn't respond to. Later she filed 125 in Bangalore in Feb 2021, which I came to know about only in July 2022 via email. In her petition she mentioned i am working and earning 20L pa and demanded 60K maintenance plus 50L for damages caused to her by mental and physical harassment. She was not working.

She had used blore pg as an address for filing case as her brother was working and living there. I came to know from pg caretaker she had left that pg long ago and she had also said she was with her parents in LKO to take care of them during mediations.

I have not been working since 2018 and lost all my life savings by 2023 end in stocks trading. I also took loan of 15L and lost that too in market. I joined a job for 1.5 years of 30Kpm and later that company defaulted. In last couple of years I had some earnings by way of independent financial advisory and some rental income but both have now almost stopped.

I am currently unemployed. I suffer from mental depression, anxiety, eyes, stomach problems and neuropathy. My parents died before marriage and I have an elder sister married and living as single mother of two daughters.
I hired a lawyer in blore, but he has been utterly unresponsive to my calls, msgs, emails and case status updates. I never recieved any of the case file copy or documents produced on my behalf or by wife. In the initial mediation round, wife demanded 30L which I couldn't pay but ready to live together but she denied.

I filed sec 126 and produced few proofs. As my financial condition worsened, I asked my lawyer to attend only hearings with an action point. lawyer didn't attend any hearings but charged me for few hearings in last 3 years.
Hence, my 126 got dismissed which I was not aware, and as my objections to 125 were not filed by my lawyer which I had shared earlier to him, court then finally passed order on 5-Sep-26 for interim 15K maintenance and arrears to be paid within 4 months. I was never informed about this even when I met my lawyer in Oct end. Later he just sent me Order sheet on 10-Nov.

What is the way forward now? shall I change my lawyer?
Suggest..
Asked 8 hours ago in Family Law
Religion: Hindu

First answer received in 30 minutes.

Lawyers are available now to answer your questions.

6 Answers


you should immediately change your lawyer

 

and take urgent legal steps in the Bangalore Family Court (or High Court, depending on the specific order) before the 4-month deadline for paying arrears expires in early January 2027.

 

 

2)Failing to file objections despite receiving instructions and hiding a final interim order for two months is gross negligence. Mentioning that you may approach the Karnataka State Bar Council often compels unresponsive lawyers to hand over the NOC promptly.





 

3)your new lawyer can file an application to recall/set aside the interim order, arguing that a litigant should not suffer due to the fault of their advocate.

 

 Usually, an application to set aside an ex-parte order must be filed within 3 months of the order or knowledge of the order. Since you only received the order sheet on 10-Nov-2026, act immediately so you are well within the limitation period.

 


 

4) If the Family Court refuses to entertain a recall/modification, your lawyer can file a Revision Petition before the Karnataka High Court challenging the interim maintenance order and seeking an immediate stay on the arrears.

Ajay Sethi
Advocate, Mumbai
101111 Answers
8261 Consultations

If you are not satisfied with your lawyer's handling of your case, you may very well entrust your case to some other lawyer of your choice, if your present counsel gives you no objection. Of course, you may need to pay arrears of his/her professional fees, if any. Instruct your new advocate to strongly oppose the maintenance order basing your defence on documentary evidence of your current financial status. Good luck!

Swaminathan Neelakantan
Advocate, Coimbatore
3247 Answers
20 Consultations

The most urgent task is to immediately replace the lawyer, and first file a recall application with the original trial court to challenge the September 5 ex parte order. According to Indian law, you do not need to directly appeal to the High Court; you should first apply under Section 126(2) CrPC (or the corresponding provision of the BNSS) to set aside the ex parte order. Since you were not properly notified and your lawyer failed to appear, this constitutes "good cause" for applying to set aside.

On the substantive aspects, your chances of defending are limited: the Supreme Court has clearly held that a husband cannot evade maintenance obligations simply by claiming unemployment; as long as he is able-bodied and capable of earning, the court may presume "notional income". Although your wife has a master's degree and work experience, the case law generally does not exempt the husband from liability merely because the wife has earning capacity. However, you can still argue that your actual income is zero and your health condition is poor, requesting a reduction in the amount.

Action sequence: 1. Find a reliable new lawyer; 2. Immediately file a recall application; 3. Simultaneously collect evidence of your unemployment, medical records, and proof that the original lawyer failed to perform duties, for use in subsequent hearings.

Lalit Saxena
Advocate, Sonbhadra
582 Answers

You must change your lawyer immediately. Keeping an advocate who fails to file objections, lets an application get dismissed without notice, and hides an adverse order for two months is a severe professional lapse that has directly resulted in a ₹15,000/month interim maintenance order and an arrears deadline against you.

Since  the order was passed on 5 September 2026 and gives you 4 months (until roughly 5 January 2027) to clear arrears, you are in a time-critical window. If you do not get a stay or modification before January 2027, your wife can file an execution petition (under Section 125(3) CrPC / Section 144(3) BNSS), which can lead to attachment of assets or an arrest warrant.

When your objections and Affidavit of Assets and Liabilities (mandatory under the Supreme Court's Rajnesh v. Neha guidelines) are finally placed before the court, focus on these documented facts:

Courts assess maintenance based on current earning capacity, not hypothetical figures from 8 years ago. Submit your Income Tax Returns (ITRs) from 2018 to 2026, bank statements showing depleted balances, Demat/trading loss statements, loan default/debt documents, and medical records for your depression, anxiety, neuropathy, and eye/stomach conditions.

Highlight that she holds a Master's degree and had 7 years of prior work experience. Under settled law (such as Mamta Jaiswal and Rajnesh v. Neha), a well-qualified spouse capable of earning cannot sit idle merely to claim maintenance, and she is required to file her own bank statements and ITRs exposing any undisclosed income.

Put on record that she left in August 2016 without any FIR or genuine domestic violence finding, refused reconciliation, and signed a receipt acknowledging the return of all her jewelry and belongings.

Use the PG caretaker's details, her statements during mediation about living with her parents in Lucknow, and her address from the earlier mutual consent divorce petition in MP to show Bangalore has no jurisdiction.

T Kalaiselvan
Advocate, Vellore
91319 Answers
2529 Consultations

Based on the facts shared, I would strongly recommend changing your lawyer immediately and taking urgent steps to challenge the interim maintenance order dated 5 September 2026. The matter should not be left unattended, particularly because the order directs payment of arrears within four months.

There are two issues to address: challenging the maintenance order on its merits and examining whether the order was passed without your objections and financial documents being properly placed before the Court, and without you being informed of the proceedings by your previous counsel.

The fact that you were unemployed or that your wife had previously been employed may be relevant, but neither fact by itself automatically defeats a maintenance claim. The Court will examine the parties' present financial circumstances, earning capacity, qualifications, assets, liabilities and other relevant factors.

You should immediately obtain the certified copy of the order dated 5 September 2026, the complete order sheets, your wife's maintenance petition, your objections, documents filed by both sides, the application filed under Section 126 CrPC and the order dismissing that application. You should also verify whether summons were properly served and whether your previous advocate was appearing on your behalf.

The appropriate remedy will depend on whether the order was passed by a Magistrate or a Family Court and whether the proceedings were decided ex parte. We can examine the possibility of seeking recall or setting aside of the ex parte order, wherever applicable, and/or challenging the order before the competent revisional or constitutional court.

Since the maintenance proceedings were instituted in February 2021, they would ordinarily continue under the CrPC under the applicable savings provisions. Section 126(2) CrPC provides for setting aside an ex parte maintenance order on sufficient cause being shown, ordinarily within three months from the date of the order. Since the order is dated 5 September 2026, this aspect requires immediate attention.

Your case must be supported by documentary evidence rather than merely stating that you are unemployed. We should prepare a comprehensive affidavit of income, assets and liabilities, supported by bank statements, income tax returns, employment and salary records, proof of termination or closure of employment, details of loans and outstanding liabilities, evidence of reduction in your financial advisory and rental income, and medical records supporting your health-related difficulties.

Your wife's educational qualifications, Master's degree, seven years of previous work experience and last drawn salary of ₹18,000 per month are relevant considerations. We should also investigate whether she is presently employed or earning independently. However, merely being educated or previously employed does not automatically disentitle her from maintenance. The Court will examine whether she has sufficient independent income to maintain herself.

We should also examine the territorial jurisdiction of the Bengaluru Court. Since you have stated that your wife was residing in a PG accommodation in Bengaluru and may have shifted to Lucknow before filing the maintenance petition, we should verify her actual place of residence when the petition was instituted in February 2021. If she was not residing in Bengaluru at that time and no other statutory ground of jurisdiction existed, a territorial jurisdiction objection may be available.

In my assessment, there are grounds requiring serious examination, particularly the alleged failure of your previous advocate to file objections, the dismissal of your Section 126 application, the absence of proper consideration of your financial documents and the question of territorial jurisdiction.

However, I would not advise you to stop paying or ignore the maintenance order merely because you intend to challenge it. Unless the competent Court stays or modifies the order, it remains operative and arrears may continue to accumulate.

My advice is to change your counsel immediately and have the matter taken up on an urgent basis. The first priority should be to obtain the complete court record and determine the appropriate remedy before the limitation period becomes an issue.

Please share the order dated 5 September 2026, the latest order sheet, the order dismissing your Section 126 application, the original maintenance petition and the objections/documents you had shared with your previous lawyer. After examining these documents, we can formulate the appropriate challenge and seek interim protection against coercive recovery, wherever legally justified.

For detailed legal advise you may connect on https://share.google/jCbuYXivLzFBy0dSK

Yuganshu Sharma
Advocate, Delhi
1683 Answers
5 Consultations

You appear to have two separate issues requiring immediate attention: challenging the interim maintenance order dated 05.09.2026 and addressing the serious lapses in representation by your existing counsel. Both need to be handled carefully, particularly because the court has directed payment of arrears within four months.

First, yes, I would seriously consider changing your lawyer. A counsel's failure to communicate court orders, keep you informed of proceedings and place your objections and supporting documents before the court can materially prejudice your defence. However, changing counsel alone will not remedy the situation; the next procedural steps are more important.

Second, the order dated 05.09.2026 needs urgent examination. Since the original maintenance proceedings were instituted in February 2021, the applicable procedural framework would ordinarily remain the CrPC, owing to the pending-proceedings savings under the BNSS.

There are potentially two courses of action:

  • Recall of the order: If the interim maintenance order was passed ex parte, Section 126(2) CrPC provides a remedy to seek setting aside of such an order on showing sufficient cause. The statutory three-month period makes this particularly urgent in your case. Since the order is dated 05.09.2026, you should not delay.

  • Challenge or modification: Depending upon the nature of the order and the proceedings, an appropriate challenge before the Karnataka High Court or an application before the Family Court may be considered. The precise remedy needs to be determined after examining the orders. Merely filing a revision against an interim maintenance order may not be maintainable.


    Third, you have some relevant grounds on the merits of maintenance. Your wife's educational qualifications, Master's degree and seven years of pre-marital work experience are relevant considerations. Her actual earning capacity and present income need to be examined. However, being educated or having worked before marriage does not automatically disentitle a wife to maintenance.

Equally important is your present financial position. Your unemployment since 2018, failed employment, cessation of advisory income, rental income, financial liabilities and medical circumstances need to be properly documented. The Supreme Court in Rajnesh v. Neha (2020) has laid down detailed guidelines requiring disclosure of income, assets and liabilities by both parties. The court must consider the actual financial circumstances of both spouses while determining maintenance.

I would also examine whether your wife's Bangalore address was her actual place of residence when she instituted the proceedings. Section 126 CrPC permits proceedings where the wife resides, but the mere fact that her brother lived in Bangalore does not, by itself, establish jurisdiction.

My immediate recommendation: Change your counsel, obtain the complete certified court record, including your wife's petition, your objections, the order sheets, the order dismissing your Section 126 application and the interim maintenance order. Do not rely merely on the order sheet forwarded by your existing lawyer. Also, do not ignore the arrears direction; seek appropriate interim protection rather than assuming that filing a challenge automatically stays recovery.

There are three aspects I would particularly want to examine before advising you on the strongest course of action:

  1. Was the order dated 05.09.2026 passed after hearing both parties, or was it effectively an ex parte order because your counsel failed to appear or file objections?

  2. What exactly was the Section 126 application that you filed, and on what grounds was it dismissed?

  3. Did the Family Court determine your income on the basis of any documentary evidence, or did it simply accept your wife's allegation of annual income of ₹20 lakh?

These details can substantially change the legal remedy available to you. In particular, I would not advise you to accept the ₹15,000 monthly liability without first examining whether the order can be recalled, challenged or appropriately modified.

If you can share the order dated 05.09.2026 and the order dismissing your Section 126 application, the available legal remedies and their procedural viability can be assessed much more precisely.

Indu Verma
Advocate, Chandigarh
382 Answers
10 Consultations

Ask a Lawyer

Get legal answers from lawyers in 1 hour. It's quick, easy, and anonymous!
  Ask a lawyer